The Pony

One of OTR's genuine neighborhood bars, tucked into Main Street with a layout that does exactly what it should — booths along one wall, a handsome bar built from salvaged Kentucky doors and a reclaimed mantelpiece along the other. The menu is tight and intentional: burgers, wings, beef on weck, a Friday fish fry done in Modelo Negra beer batter, and hand-cut fries. Honey mustard wings and habanero garlic wings have developed their own following. A Buffalo Bills stronghold with a relaxed regulars crowd and no pretense. The kind of bar OTR doesn't make enough of anymore.