Lucy Blue Pizza (Anderson Township)

Founded 2001 by Jim Thompson as a late-night pizza window at 12th & Walnut in OTR. Family-owned and operated—Jim and wife Lynn (co-owner/designer), daughter Taylor Casto (co-owner/GM). Original dough recipe made fresh by hand daily. Premium ingredients, no canned anything. BamaQue Pickle Pizza became a cult favorite. Buffalo Chicken now a full-time menu item. Homemade lasagna available seasonally (take & bake). Steak hoagies, fresh salads, chicken parm. Historic Clough Pike location serves the east side suburbs.